Common Issues Requiring Estate Litigation in Arizona
Estate litigation can arise in Arizona in numerous areas. Some common issues that often arise in Arizona estate litigation include:
Will Contests: A party may challenge the validity of a will for several reasons, including
Allegations of undue influence, where someone exerts improper pressure on the decedent to change their will
Claims of lack of testamentary capacity, meaning the decedent was not mentally competent when making or changing their will.
Improper execution or noncompliance with statutory requirements for the creation of a will.
Forgery – where someone copies and pastes a signature from another document or otherwise fabricates the decedent’s signature on a will.
Trust Disputes: Trusts can be disputed for similar reasons as wills, such as undue influence, lack of capacity, or improper formation.
Beneficiary Disputes: Sometimes beneficiaries disagree about the interpretation of a will or trust or what the decedent wanted, leading to disputes over their rights and benefits.
Fiduciary Duty Breaches: Executors, trustees, and personal representatives have a fiduciary duty to beneficiaries to act in their best interest and manage the assets of the estate or trust appropriately. Allegations of mismanagement, embezzlement, excess compensation or self-dealing can result in disputes and litigation.
Joint Property and Account Issues: Estate litigation can arise outside the context of the actual estate. Such disputes can arise when the deceased person held property or accounts jointly with someone else, and there is a dispute about the nature of the joint ownership and the rights of the surviving joint holder. This could include questions about undue influence, mental capacity, fraud and forgery, just like a will contest.
Claims Against the Estate: Before assets can be distributed to beneficiaries, valid debts and creditor claims against the estate must be settled. Disputes can arise over which claims are valid and should be paid. Sometimes it is necessary to wait to address creditor claims until after any estate litigation is resolved or vice versa.
Spousal Rights: Arizona is a community property state, meaning spouses generally have equal ownership of assets acquired during the marriage. Disputes can arise if a will or trust does not adequately provide for the surviving spouse.
Lack of Clarity: Vague or ambiguous language in a will or trust can lead to disputes over interpretation and enforcement
Elective Share Rights: In some states, a surviving spouse can choose to take an “elective share” or statutory portion of the deceased spouse’s estate, regardless of what the will says. This can lead to disputes if the will provides for a smaller portion than the statutory share.
Undocumented Gifts or Transfers: Disputes can arise over assets transferred by the decedent before death, especially if the intent behind the transfer is not clear. This can lead to claims for financial exploitation of a vulnerable adult, another type of estate litigation.
Challenges to the Appointment of Personal Representative/Executor: Sometimes family members or other interested parties may contest the appointment of a particular person as the executor or personal representative of an estate, usually based on claims of incompetence or bias.
Disputes over Disposition of Remains: On occasion, the decedent does not leave clear direction on the disposition of their remains, such as whether they want to be buried or cremated. Surviving family may disagree on how to dispose of the remains, which may lead to litigation asking the Court to decide.
How can trustee misconduct be identified and proven?
Trustee misconduct, or a breach of fiduciary duty, occurs when a trustee fails to fulfill their legal obligations to the beneficiaries of a trust. Identifying and proving trustee misconduct requires an understanding of the trustee’s duties and a close examination of their actions (or inactions). Discovering and proving trustee misconduct varies by case and situation. Here are some steps and methods for identifying and proving trustee misconduct:
Sign Up For Our Newsletter
Contact Us Today
Understand the Trustee’s Duties: The trustee has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. This includes duties of loyalty, impartiality, prudence, and transparency, among others. By understanding these duties, one can better identify when they are breached.
Review Trust Documents: The trustee’s duties are primarily governed by the terms of the trust. So it is always a good idea to obtain and read a copy of the trust document, as well as any amendments. They will lay out the trustee’s specific responsibilities and any particular requirements or restrictions.
Examine Financial Records: Mismanagement or misappropriation of trust assets is a common form of trustee misconduct. By closely reviewing bank statements, investment records, receipts, and other financial documents, one can identify discrepancies or questionable transactions. This might involve:
- Unauthorized or imprudent investments.
- Personal use of trust funds.
- Failure to account for or distribute trust assets.
- Excess compensation.
Demand an Accounting: Beneficiaries often have the right to request a formal accounting or at least information showing the trust’s assets, liabilities, receipts, and disbursements. If the trustee fails to provide this or provides an incomplete or suspicious accounting, it may be evidence of misconduct.
Look for Conflicts of Interest: A trustee should not engage in transactions that could benefit them personally at the expense of the trust or its beneficiaries. Such transactions may be subject to challenge if not specifically authorized in the trust.
Communication (or Lack Thereof): If the trustee fails to communicate important information to the beneficiaries or is unresponsive to legitimate inquiries, it may indicate neglect or other misconduct.
Consider the Treatment of Beneficiaries: A trustee should treat all beneficiaries impartially, unless the trust document specifies otherwise. If one beneficiary is favored over another without justification, it might indicate misconduct.
Gather Witness Testimony: Other individuals may have information about the trustee’s actions, decisions, or intentions. Their testimony could be crucial in proving misconduct.
Hire an Expert: In some cases, especially where financial impropriety is suspected, it may be beneficial to hire a forensic accountant or another expert to examine the trust’s finances.
Seek Legal Counsel: An attorney who specializes in trusts and estates can help identify misconduct, gather evidence, and represent the interests of the beneficiaries in court.
Initiate Legal Proceedings: If there’s enough evidence, beneficiaries can file a lawsuit against the trustee for breach of fiduciary duty. Through the legal process, more evidence can be obtained via discovery methods such as depositions, interrogatories, and requests for documents.
Remember, the burden of proof generally lies with the person alleging the misconduct. As such, it’s crucial to gather strong, compelling evidence if pursuing a claim against a trustee.
Contact Berk Law Group
Estate disputes and trustee litigation can arise in these and other circumstances. If you believe you have a claim or concern regarding an estate or trust in Arizona, it’s advisable to consult with an attorney who specializes in estate and trust litigation, such as Berk Law Group. If you have any questions, don’t hesitate to contact the experienced and caring team at Berk Law Group.
